#InauguralReview @madeinnypizza #MadeInNewYorkPizza #UpperWestSide #2563Broadway at 96th Street
Peachy and her favorite pizza right now: Margherita Stracciatella
It's not who you know, it's WHOM YOU KNOW and one of the newer pizza places to us that is absolutely superior and completely dominant in New York style pizza is Made in New York Pizza; it earned an inaugural review in 2022 and advanced to Peachy's Picks in 2023 at the 421 Amsterdam Avenue location! They were last featured in February of this year, and as we always say, what do the best do?
Answer: they get better!
We are delighted to tell you that they have opened a BRAND NEW LOCATION AT 2563 BROADWAY AT 96TH STREET!!!! We hope we are the first to tell you and it is the exact same menu that we know and love from their prior Amsterdam location. As usual, we started with the House Salad, above, and the Caesar Salad, below. All elements were completely fresh and cut well, and they put the dressing on the side as instructed: Ranch and Caesar, respectively.
The high level of consistency that this brand delivers with the Chicken Roll is truly commendable, and the freshness of the bread, the majesty of the cheese and sauce combination in perfect proportion and the juicy (note not at all dried out like lesser places we don't tell you about) chicken make this a winner again. And we normally don't find garlic knots great across the board at all places because they lack freshness, however, THESE GARLIC KNOTS ARE ABSOLUTELY FRESH AND THE BEST WE HAVE HAD ANYWHERE AT ALL IN 2025. MADE IN NEW YORK PIZZA IS IN IT TO WIN IT.
Note we never edit pictures.
The total truth is your Garlic Knots should smile at you like these do!
You win like Made in New York Pizza or we do not publish.
All hail pizza perfection: namely, the Margherita Stracciatella!
It is the piece de resistance at this venue, and now we have had it a second time.
It is more ingrained ever in our taste levels that this is simply the masterpiece, the creme de la creme of pizzas! You are not living your best life until you eat the creamy cheese just oozing in its perfection among the fields of tomato and basil on a perfectly fresh and strong crust to support the excellence it holds up. We absolutely cannot wait to meet it again and we can assure you, it did not last long and this is so superior, you are not going to want to share it. Make whomever you dine with order their own.
If you don't think pizza is elegant or decadent we would say you are just eating the wrong pizza.
Looks like Frank agrees with us but we would never eat just one bite anywhere if we love you!
The Pepperoni Wheel will make your appetite go vroom with its carnivorous pepperoni combined with delicious cheese! The marinara on the side for any of these sides, particularly the cheese calzone, is totally key and elevates your experience.
Peachy is a big fan of vegetables on pizza, and the eighteen inch wonder that is called Mushroom we chose to add red peppers and onions to to make it a trifecta of nutrition! We customized this: there is a Square Veggie Pizza on the menu however we have a pronounced affinity for 18 inch round traditional New York pizza. Every bite was just as amazing as we had hoped and we certainly feel this is a healthy winner! (Note Peachy is not a nutritionist!)
The decadent crescent called Cheese Calzone says enchante with its perfect ratio of mozzarella and ricotta hidden inside ready to ravish your taste buds! Like the Garlic Knots, we feel this exact Calzone is the one to beat and the best in New York.
Made in New York Pizza continues to be Highly Recommended.
We look forward to seeing them keep up the excellence!
