#PeachysPicks #TerrificTakeout #BenitoOne Since 1968 A Peachy's Pick Since 2013 by #RobertIanniello Summer 2026 174 Mulberry Street #Manhattan #LittleItaly
The Undisputed Crowning Glory of the menu: Lobster Ravioli!!!!
The stuff dreams are made of.
The stuffing is custom made in a proprietary method by General Manager James Bari himself and carefully crafted into the Ravioli itself just around the corner, maximizing freshness and premium quality in every bite.
James Bari and Peachy Deegan with the cold antipasto for two
It's not who you know, it's WHOM YOU KNOW and we know Benito One! We have been going there since 2013, when it first earned a spot in Peachy's Picks and it continues to thrive in Manhattan's Little Italy. When a restaurant is older than Peachy, you know their longevity is quite often testament to their success. We were immediately welcomed with the succulent Eggplant Rollatini, which is quite the modern classic. Spiedini Alla Romana with capers in a light anchovy sauce followed up this Italian wonder with an echo of classic culinary prowess that distinguishes Benito One. Many lesser venues have all the usual suspects but Benito One rises to the occasion and celebrates nuances of Italian cuisine like this appetizer that uniquely announces they are in it to win it with the fabulous flavor.
If for some reason you have not read our previous 31,000 posts, you should know that we never edit pictures. You win like Benito One, or we do not publish. Carciofo Ripieno: Stuffed artichoke with pepato cheese, Garlic and olive oil said to us: don't hate me because I'm beautiful.
Eat me Peachy!
And so she obeyed, and it lived happily ever after in her stomach. It's gorgeously highlighted with that premium pepato, which perfectly punctuates the awesome artichoke.
Chicken Parm, how we love you! And you know we count the ways. Peachy Deegan might have the only column dedicated to Chicken Parm because she is just that crazy about it. The red sauce across the board here is incredibly irresistible and is a major asset of this dish, and this was just as perfect as our previous visit in 2024. It literally melts in your mouth and they even remembered to put the dressing on the side as the picky one in residence here requested for the salad we chose to come with the majestic Chicken Parm. Chicken Parm doesn't get any better than this: it is pure perfection consistently and it is the envy of a lot of big restaurant groups who might favor nonsense style over lacking substance. This Chicken Parm simply cannot be beat: it is among the very best. The only element better than this is the Lobster Ravioli.
The angel on Peachy's shoulder reminded her to order some green vegetables, and the sauteed Broccoli Rabe in Garlic and Olive Oil was not only a nutritional triumph, but also a delicious one.
If you have met Peachy, you know her height bears a striking resemblance to shrimp.
It is even better when the shrimp eats one!
Shrimp Fra Diavolo reminds you that Robert also owns Umberto's Clam House which is an Italian Seafood celebration in itself; now that Robert also owns Benito One since November 2023 you can be even more assured of the seafood quality. A fun fact is that Umberto, Robert's Dad, was close friends with James Bari, the current General Manager and previous owner since 2011. We told you it was not who you know, it's WHOM YOU KNOW. And yes, the tantalizing shrimp stepping out in red will seal the deal on a successful dinner!
It will be pure fireworks when you begin to indulge in the superior lobster ravioli.
As mentioned above, James personally makes the interior stuffing and remember readers, these pictures are unedited and the truth is they look exactly this spectacular.
Every bite is a culinary triumph and the envy of lesser run-of-the-mill places that will inevitably come and go, while Benito One endures and celebrates true authentic Italian excellence.
Lobster ravioli reaches the upper echelons of flavor ecstasy and we cannot get enough of it.
Peachy nearly cries when it is all gone. But you know she'll be back and terminate the next plate in good time.
The 14 Oz Pork chop with sweet and hot peppers, onions & potatoes is sure to wow all our carnivorous readers and the generous size is only outdone by the magnificent quality of the pork chop, so beautifully highlighted by these vegetables.
The 14 Oz Pork chop with sweet and hot peppers, onions & potatoes is sure to wow all our carnivorous readers and the generous size is only outdone by the magnificent quality of the pork chop, so beautifully highlighted by these vegetables.
There are rarely menu modifications at Benito One because of the overwhelming demand of what is on the menu now and we believe it has tremendous depth, especially for their size.
44 inside seats are here and 32 outdoor seats are additionally available.
James tells us the original restaurant had 16 seats!
We also understand that 90 percent of the clientele are return customers says James Bari; this is one more reason to go here!
Not all Cold Antipastis are created equally.
Some are just superior.
And this is especially fantastic on a hot day like right now, crafted with premium Italian ingredients: Smoked mozzarella, prosciutto, roasted peppers, soppressata, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, olives, gabaladina, provolone, & fontina cheese team up for a final victory lap in this review and ultimately, your stomach!
Benito One continues to be Highly Recommended by Whom You Know.
And, drumroll please, THEY NOW HAVE A WEBSITE FOR THE FIRST TIME IN OUR REVIEW HISTORY.
And thanks to Peachy's Pal Grok for including them too at her humble suggestion!
212 226 9171
Benito One
174 Mulberry Street
Little Italy
Manhattan
New York, New York!















