All Columns in Alphabetical Order

Monday, April 10, 2023

#PeachysPicks #Manhattan #TerrificTakeout #OldTown #OldTownBar #OldTownRestaurant #WhomYouKnow #PeachyDeegan @ManhattanPeachy A Peachy's Pick Since 2015, Old Town Bar & Restaurant Est. 1892 by Gerard Meagher and the Meagher Family Spring 2023

Best Burger so says Mayor Bloomberg and Peachy
Owner Gerard Meagher who owns Old Town Bar and Restaurant with his brothers and sisters
Pack it up pack it in, let us begin, we only feature the best cause if you aren't it's a sin.  Get up out of your seat and jump around and march yourself to 45 East 18th Street and believe it or not we just realized that this is in the House of Pain video. (read wiki) During this high holy season of Stanley Cup Playoffs (April 17 start), you will hear this song a lot in-between puck drops.  No one should be surprised we are into hockey music as we were highly influenced by it in Hartford, and all of that music was in Air.
There are lots of bars in New York.
And just like the prodigal son we've returned
Everything on the menu excels we've learned
Cause they've got Guinness when you have none
If you've come to dinner don't walk there, run 

Peachy and Gerard!
They're the cream of the crop, they rise to the top, and you should always get the chili cause Peachy said they've got props!
Old Town has been a Peachy's Pick since 2015 and Old Town was last featured in 2022:
Upstairs!  Check out the historic urinals if you are a man.  We have yet to see them.
Spring is here and in addition to flowers, burgers always bloom at Gerard's place. Meagan and Chrissy always add to the positivity and sparkle of your visit.
Do not miss the history section of the menu!  
Both Peachy and Gerard are IRISH.  As a Guinness connoisseur, Peachy Deegan has been to Dublin and to the Guinness factory there and as a resident of Ireland at one time, she is a Guinness expert.  Old Town is the best Guinness in New York.  Period.
You are not living your best life if you are not eating the cheeseburgers at Old Town.
Pictures do not lie and we never, ever edit pictures.  Ours was perfectly medium rare as ordered.
Try not to lick your computer before you arrive at East 18th street.
Cheddar came to this party and this burger was eliminated by Peachy in record time with the utmost enjoyment.
Peachy absolutely lives for the cup of chili here, and in real life she did not even eat chili ever because all chili to her tasted like dog food before she met Gerard.  Gerard's chili tastes like filet mignon.  Only eat chili at Old Town!!!  It is divine.
Does your chili smile at you like this?
Also we think we hear it saying: LET'S GO RANGERS!
The Club salad is a meal in itself with its greenery, tomatoes, BACON, swiss cheese and is stepped up further with gorgeous grilled chicken.  Yes we said BACON and it comes to this party in style and you won't be able to stop eating it.  They listen and put the dressing on the side for Ms. SuperPicky.
The fried flounder sandwich is another excellent choice that absolutely hits the spot as we go into the summery season.  Every element of this winner right down to the spectacular tartar sauce will win you over and it is perfectly crisp!
We commend the salad selection at Old Town and can assure you it is super fresh.  The caesar salad reigns supreme with its romaine, tomato, garlic anchovies, parm and croutons and is spring perfection exemplified.
They've got the skills, come get your fill, cause when they make the burger they know how to grill.

Old Town Bar and Restaurant by the Meagher family continues to be Highly Recommended by Whom You Know.

Back to TOP